Jump to content

Subway - What If?


VWM

Recommended Posts

(A) trains run 8th Ave Local.

(E) trains run via 8th Avenue Express from 14th Street to Jamaica Center.

(D) trains runs on the 6th Avenue local track from B'way Lafayette to Rock Center.

(B) trains run in two sections, Brighton Beach to 57th St-7th Ave and 34th St-Herald Square and 145th St/Bedford Pk Blvd.

(M) trains run in two sections, Metropolitan Ave to Jay St (Extended to help the (A)(C)) and 71st Ave to 34th St-8th Ave with the (E).

 

 

Track Maps

 

Check out the link above and use it as a reference for when you solve these. There's certain things that you've said that go against the track maps.

 

- If the (E) is going to go express on 8th Avenue, it has to start from Canal Street (and skip Spring Street)

- The (M) cannot go to Jay Street via the (A)(C) (It can via Nassau and the (R) but nobody would do that and that wouldn't provide any relief for the A/C)

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Replies 6.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Track Maps

 

Check out the link above and use it as a reference for when you solve these. There's certain things that you've said that go against the track maps.

 

- If the (E) is going to go express on 8th Avenue, it has to start from Canal Street (and skip Spring Street)

- The (M) cannot go to Jay Street via the (A)(C) (It can via Nassau and the (R) but nobody would do that and that wouldn't provide any relief for the A/C)

 

 

Sorry about that with the (M). I meant for it to run via Montague. I see how that does not help.

 

(A) trains switch to the local track right before 59th Street/Columbus Cir.

(A) trains run local from there.

(E) trains can switch to the express track right after 50th St. They normally switch to the local track. They can terminate at 14th using the switches between 23rd and 34th St.

 

My edited version:

 

(A) trains run 8th Ave Local.

(E) trains run via 8th Avenue Express from 14th Street to Jamaica Center.

(D) trains runs on the 6th Avenue local track from B'way Lafayette to Rock Center.

(B) trains run in two sections, Brighton Beach to 57th St-7th Ave and 34th St-Herald Square and 145th St/Bedford Pk Blvd.

(M) trains run in two sections 14th Street, 8th Avenue to 71st Ave and Metropolitan Ave to Chambers/Broad St.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

(B)(D) run local via 6th Avenue

 

 

(B)(D) trains can't run via local.

 

Okay, I'm going to re-write my scenario because I've gotta change some things:

No trains can terminate at WTC due to a derailment. Because of flooding the 6 Av express tracks at West 4 St are unusable. Rules: 30 TPH total service must be maintained on both the 6 Av and 8 Av lines.

 

 

(B)(D) Runs in two sections:

Between Bronx and 34 Street-Herald Square.

Between 34 Street-Herald Square (B) via Broadway Express, Broadway-Laffayette (D) and Brooklyn.

 

(E) Terminates at Chambers Street (A)(C) platform or Canal Street, both using the unused middle track.

Edited by TrainFanInfinity
Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXT

No trains may pass through Chambers Street (A)(C). The World Trade Center (E) station is unaffected.

 

 

(A) 207 St to Lefferts Blvd/Far Rockaway (UPW/CPW/8 Av/6 Av Local/Fulton Express)

(C) Euclid Av to Jay St (Fulton Local)

(M) Metro Av to Chambers St/Broad St (Nassau Local)

 

NOTE

(C) trains may go to Fulton St

Link to comment
Share on other sites

(A) and (C) travel via the (F) between Jay St and W 4 st in both directions.

 

The MTA finally does fast track on the Broadway line.

 

 

I'm guessing this is a scenario so, assuming it's Queensboro Plaza-Whitehall Street:

 

(N): No trains between Whitehall Street and Queensboro Plaza.

(Q): No trains between Whitehall Street and 57th Street.

(R): Trains run all night to 21st Street-Queensbridge to replace Broadway Line service, via 6th Avenue and 63rd Street.

(7): Extra trains run between Queensboro Plaza and Times Square.

Edited by ThrexxBus
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Q43LTD, that is too much TPH. A track can only use 30TPH. Also what do you mean by the Broadway Line. Canal Street to 57th St or 57th to Whitehall.

 

I'll use Whitehall.

 

(R) trains run in two sections,57th Street to 71st Avenue and Whitehall St to 96th Street.

(N) trains run from Whitehall to Coney Island.

(Q) trains run via 6th Avenue to 21st Street Queensbridge.

Extra trains signed as (N) run from 57th Street to Ditmars Blvd.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Next:

The MTA does Fastrack on Central Park West. All stations between 145th Street and 59th Street-Columbus Circle are closed.

 

 

 

(A) trains run in two sections, 59th Street to Rockway/Lefferts and 145th to 207th. (A) trains run local from 145th.

 

(C) trains from Euclid to 59th Street.

 

 

(D) trains run in two sections - Coney Island to 59th Street and 145th Street* to 205th St.

*At 145th Street trains terminate on the Concourse express platform and skip 155th St. Then trains switch to the local track right before 161st/Yankees. (D) trains run local to 205th St.

 

(B) trains run from Brighton Beach to 57th St-7th Ave via Broadway.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I had my way, I'd do the FASTRACK between 125 St and 59 St, but anyway:

 

(A) Queens - 59 St-Columbus Circle, local

(A) 207 St - 145 St; uptown trains skip 155 St and 163 St

(B) suspended

(C) suspended

(D) Coney Island - 59 St

(D) 205 St - 145 St; skips 155 St

 

(2)(3) runs local; (3) trains run to New Lots Av through the night

 

Shuttle buses run:

https://maps.google.com/maps/ms?msid=209448607233497620315.0004c67517577db6536cf&msa=0&ll=40.81212,-73.960819&spn=0.102769,0.141964

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Return of Monstrosity.

 

NEXT:

West 4 Street-Washington Square is impassable due to a wall collapse.

 

Affected: (A)(B)(C)(D)(E)(F)(M)

 

BONUS:

Trains cannot terminate at 34 Street-Herald Square or on the Nassau Street Line. REMINDER: This is just a bonus.

 

EXTREME BONUS:

Fulton Street Center also collapses, and the stations planned to be part of it are shut down. (Do this at your own risk. :P

Affected: (A)(C)(E)(J)(Z)(R)(2)(3)(4)(5) + (B)(D)(F)(M)

 

If you do the extra bonus, you get a cookie, and remember, this is probably long term :lol:

Edited by TrainFanInfinity
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Next:

The MTA does Fastrack on Central Park West. All stations between 145th Street and 59th Street-Columbus Circle are closed.

 

Easy.

 

(A) runs between 207th and 145th and 59th to Lefferts/Rockaways

(D) runs between 205th and 145th and 59th and Coney Island

 

Guys, remember FASTRACK means overnight, and the (B)(C) don't run then.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Return of Monstrosity.

 

NEXT:

West 4 Street-Washington Square is impassable due to a wall collapse.

 

Affected: A B C D E F M

 

BONUS:

Trains cannot terminate at 34 Street-Herald Square or on the Nassau Street Line. REMINDER: This is just a bonus.

 

EXTREME BONUS:

Fulton Street Center also collapses, and the stations planned to be part of it are shut down. (Do this at your own risk. :P

Affected: A C E J Z R 2 3 4 5 B D F M

 

If you do the extra bonus, you get a cookie, and remember, this is probably long term :lol:

 

Long term, so I get to do whatever reroutes I want. Nice...

 

This includes the problem and Xtreme bonus.

So here's the list of closed stations:

Fulton St

Cortlandt St (R)

West 4 St

WTC/Park Place

 

Here goes...

 

(2) No trains between Chambers St and Wall St.

(3) No trains between 14 St and Wall St.

(4) No trains between Brooklyn Bridge and Wall St.

(5) No trains between 42 St and Flatbush Av.

(A) No trains between 34 St-Penn Station and Jay St-Metrotech.

(B) No trains between B'way Lafayette and 34 St. Yes, I know this isn't usually possible, but this requirement would most likely be bypassed (by having staff on site) since this is a long-term change.

(C) Suspended

(D) Trains run in two sections: 205 St to 34 St and Jamaica Center to Brooklyn, via 63 St, B'way Exp, and bridge.

(E) No trains between Penn Station and WTC. Runs half service.

(F) No trains between B'way Lafayette and 47/50 Sts. Trains wrong-rail between B'way Laf and 2 Av middle tracks. Selected trains operate between 34 St-Herald Sq (B'way tracks) and 179 St, via 63 St.

(J) No trains south of Chambers St.

(M) No trains between Chambers St and 71 Av.

(Q) Trains run via Broadway local to avoid switching delays. Additional (Q) trains run between Coney Island and Whitehall St.

(R) Trains run via the bridge. Additional (R) trains run between 95 St and Whitehall St.

(Z) No trains south of Chambers St.

 

NEXT

The 8 Av level of West 4 St is closed. Challenge: all outer-boro lines must have the same tph to Manhattan as before.

Affected: (A)(C)(E), others as needed.

 

The problem with these monstrosities is that it's not practical, since very few lines go anywhere useful in Manhattan and we know they will be JAMMED.

Edited by NX Express
Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXT

The 8 Av level of West 4 St is closed. Challenge: all outer-boro lines must have the same tph to Manhattan as before.

Affected: (A)(C)(E), others as needed.

 

The problem with these monstrosities is that it's not practical, since very few lines go anywhere useful in Manhattan and we know they will be JAMMED.

 

(A): Very few trains run via 6th Avenue Express, switching after West 4th. Most trains run in two sections:

34th Street-207th Street

Canal Street-Queens.

2 trains occasionally terminate at Euclid Avenue to reduce crowding in Manhattan.

 

(C): Canal Street-Euclid Avenue.

 

(E): To LER-2nd Avenue or World Trade Center.

 

(M): Chambers Street-Metro Avenue

 

_______________

 

At Canal Street:

 

Most trains layover at the center track at Chambers Street. 12 (A) trains and 6 (C) trains will dump passengers at Chambers, travel onto the center track, wait for the southbound track to clear and continue.

 

At West 4th Street:

Express: (B), (D)

Local: 6 (A) trains, (E) and (F), each 13-14 TPH, total of 32-34 TPH at that station track only. Expect delays on through (A) trains, (E), and (F) trains.

 

On 6th Avenue, b/w 14th Street and 47th Street:

Express: 6 (A) trains, (B), and (D)

Local: (E), (F)

Edited by ThrexxBus
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here's how I would do it:

(A) No trains between 34 St and Chambers St. Transfer at Chambers St to the northbound (E) train to continue your trip.

(C) No trains between 34 St and Euclid Av.

(E) Trains run via the (M) between 5 Av/53 St and West 4 St.

(M) No trains between Chambers St and 71 Av. Additional (R) trains run between 71 Av and Whitehall St.

 

NEXT: the 6 Av express tracks are flooded between 47-50 Sts and W 4 St, and can't be used. The 6 Av local tracks are flooded between 34 St-Herald Sq and 57 St, too.

 

Rules: you can't suspend any routes, and Manhattan must be served with the same TPH as normally.

 

(A) The last stop on every other northbound train is Chambers St.

(B) No trains between Bronx and 57 St/7 Av. Trains run between 57 St and Brooklyn signed as (Q).

(C) Trains run express between Chambers and 59 Sts in both directions.

(D) Trains run in two sections: Bronx to 34 St/Penn Station, and 57 St/7 Av to Brooklyn via the (Q) in Manhattan.

(F) Trains run via the (E) line in both directions between Roosevelt Av and West 4 St. Limited service operates between 57 and 179 St.

(M) No trains between Chambers St and 71 Av. Additional (R) trains run between 71 Av and Whitehall St.

(N)(Q) Trains run via the (R) between Dekalb Av and 57 St.

 

NEXT

Uptown tracks at W4 St (6 Av level) impassable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXT

Uptown tracks at W4 St (6 Av level) impassable.

 

 

(B): Suspended.

(D): No trains between West 4th Street and Whitehall Street on the (R).

(F): Northbound via 8th Avenue and 53rd Street.

(M): Some Manhattan bound (F) trains run to 2nd Avenue as (M)'s, otherwise, Chambers Street-Metro Avenue.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXT: the 6 Av express tracks are flooded between 47-50 Sts and W 4 St, and can't be used. The 6 Av local tracks are flooded between 34 St-Herald Sq and 57 St, too.

 

Rules: you can't suspend any routes, and Manhattan must be served with the same TPH as normally.

 

 

(A) The last stop on every other northbound train is Chambers St.

(B) No trains between Bronx and 57 St/7 Av. Trains run between 57 St and Brooklyn signed as (Q).

(C) Trains run express between Chambers and 59 Sts in both directions.

(D) Trains run in two sections: Bronx to 34 St/Penn Station, and 57 St/7 Av to Brooklyn via the (Q) in Manhattan.

(F) Trains run via the (E) line in both directions between Roosevelt Av and West 4 St. Limited service operates between 57 and 179 St.

(M) No trains between Chambers St and 71 Av. Additional (R) trains run between 71 Av and Whitehall St.

(N)(Q) Trains run via the (R) between Dekalb Av and 57 St.

 

Here's how I would do it:

(E) runs via 8 Av Express

(B) runs via Broadway Express and 63 St tunnel to 21 St-Queensbridge, signed as (Q)

(D) runs via 8 Av local and terminates at 2 Av

(F) runs via 8 Av local/53 St

(M) terminates at Chambers St

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXT: the 6 Av express tracks are flooded between 47-50 Sts and W 4 St, and can't be used. The 6 Av local tracks are flooded between 34 St-Herald Sq and 57 St, too.

 

Rules: you can't suspend any routes, and Manhattan must be served with the same TPH as normally.

 

 

(C) Via 8th Avenue Express south of 59 Street.

(B) Via Broadway Express to 57 Street-7 Avenue.

(D) No service between Lower East Side-2 Avenue and West 4 Street-Washington Square.

(F) Via 8th Avenue Local / 53 Street. Select trains run to Roosevelt Island.

(M) Via 8th Avenue Local

 

Summary:

8th Avenue Express = (A)(C)(D)

8th Avenue Local = (E)(F)(M)

Broadway Express = (B)(Q)

53 Street = (E)(F)(M)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Return of Monstrosity.

 

NEXT:

West 4 Street-Washington Square is impassable due to a wall collapse.

 

Affected: A B C D E F M

 

BONUS:

Trains cannot terminate at 34 Street-Herald Square or on the Nassau Street Line. REMINDER: This is just a bonus.

 

EXTREME BONUS:

Fulton Street Center also collapses, and the stations planned to be part of it are shut down. (Do this at your own risk. :P

Affected: A C E J Z R 2 3 4 5+ B D F M

 

If you do the extra bonus, you get a cookie, and remember, this is probably long term :lol:

 

 

I accidently mispelled something, I meant to say no 6th Avenue lines cannot terminate at 34 Street-Herald Square and Chambers Street. My bad. My solution. Here it goes:

 

(A) No service between 34 Street-Herald Square and High Street, via 8th Avenue Local.

(B) Suspended.

(C) No service between Manhattan and High Street.

(D) No service between 34 Street-Penn Station and Times Square-42 Street via Broadway Express.

(E) No service between 34 Street-Herald Square and World Trade Center via 63 Street.

(F) No service between 34 Street-Penn Station and Delancy Street via 53 Street.

(J)(Z) No service between Essex Street and Broad Street.

(M) No service between Myrtle Avenue-Bway and Queens.

(R) No service between City Hall Lower Level and Whitehall Street.

 

(2) No service between South Ferry and Brooklyn.

(3) No service between 14 Street and Brooklyn.

(4) No service between Brooklyn Bridge-City Hall and Wall Street.

(5) No service between East 180 Street and Wall Street, runs all times to Brooklyn.

Edited by TrainFanInfinity
Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXT: the 6 Av express tracks are flooded between 47-50 Sts and W 4 St, and can't be used. The 6 Av local tracks are flooded between 34 St-Herald Sq and 57 St, too.

 

Rules: you can't suspend any routes, and Manhattan must be served with the same TPH as normally.

 

 

(B) Coney Island to Essex St (Culver/PS/Viaduct Express/6 Av Local)

(D) Coney Island to 205 St (Culver/PS/Viaduct/CPW/8 Av/Grand CC Local)

(F) Coney Island to 179 St (Brighton/Broadway/Queens Boulevard Express)

(G) Church Av to 71 Av (Crosstown/Queens Boulevard Local)

(M) Metro Av to Chambers St/Broad St (Nassau St Local)

 

SELECT SERVICE

(B) [NORTHBOUND] Coney Island to Broadway Lafayette (Culver/PS/Viaduct Express/6 Av Local)

(B) [sOUTHBOUND] Broadway Lafayette to Coney Island (6 Av/Brighton Express)

Edited by trainguy97
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.